- Home
- Expert Series
- The Economy Of Meaning: What Efficiency Cannot Give Us
The Economy of Meaning: What Efficiency Cannot Give Us
During our conversation at Hay Festival Segovia, Hwang Bo-Reum told me why she wanted to write Welcome to the Hyunam-dong Bookshop. She missed places where people could talk about things that rarely fit into everyday conversation, such as the lives they wanted or the hopes they carried.Â
Fittingly, we were speaking at a festival built around that idea. For a few days each September, people come to Segovia to listen to writers and thinkers, but also to spend time with one another. They line up and talk between sessions, continue arguments over lunch and run into people they didn't expect to see. To me, that togetherness seems at least as important as the talks themselves.Â
Hwang's bookshop works in much the same way. It sells books and coffee, but its appeal comes from what happens around those things.Â
What technology can't replaceÂ
This isn’t a new concept. People have always looked for places to meet, exchange ideas and feel like a part of something. What's changed is the infrastructure around that desire. Social media connects us continuously, which often removes the need to share the same physical space. Many of the encounters that once happened almost by default now require a little more intention.
Technology has made much of our lives easier. In my experience, an algorithm can recommend a book remarkably well. I use technology constantly to find information, make decisions and remove unnecessary friction from daily life. AI makes many of those processes even faster, but efficiency isn't always what we're looking for.Â
There are moments when the pleasure lies in the detour: walking into a bookshop without knowing what we want or noticing a title because someone has placed it on a table. Serendipity is inefficient, and that may be part of its appeal.Â
Resonance and the economy of meaningÂ
There is a paradox in modern life: we live in a culture that prizes productivity and increasingly has the tools to optimize much of our lives. At the same time, some of the experiences we most deliberately seek out are remarkably unproductive, such as reading, talking or wandering around an exhibition.Â
The sociologist Hartmut Rosa has written about resonance as a way of thinking about our relationship with the world. His argument shifts attention away from the resources and options we accumulate and towards the quality of that relationship: whether something affects us, whether we respond to it and whether the world, in some sense, answers back.Â
I find that idea particularly helpful when thinking about culture. A museum or a festival can give us access to content, but access alone doesn't explain why we return. What often stays with us is a relationship with an idea, with a place, sometimes even with a version of ourselves that emerges there. I have come to think of this as an economy of meaning.Â
Machines answer. People listen.Â
I'm not arguing for an alternative to technology or to the conventional economy, nor do I think we should attach a higher purpose to every purchase or leisure activity. The word "purpose" has probably been asked to carry too much already.Â
What I mean is simpler: the value of an experience cannot be separated from the relationships and sense of belonging that form around it. And increasingly, digital efficiency and physical togetherness may work alongside each other rather than compete. We may discover a writer through an algorithm and then want to hear her in a room full of people. One does not invalidate the other. The easier access becomes, the clearer the value of presence.Â
There is another distinction that came through in my conversation with Hwang. Her characters do not always need their problems solved. Sometimes they need somewhere to articulate them and someone willing to listen, and that feels unmistakably human.Â
Machines are designed, in large part, to give us answers, and increasingly good ones. Human relationships are less efficient. We repeat ourselves, we hesitate or we change our minds while speaking. Often, a friend cannot solve what is troubling us, but the conversation still matters because we are being understood.Â
Belonging is built by returningÂ
Perhaps this is also why community is difficult to manufacture. Institutions can program events and create spaces, but belonging does not appear automatically when people are brought into the same room. Belonging develops through repetition, recognition and the possibility of participation.Â
Hwang's fictional bookshop offers that to its characters. It gives them somewhere to return to while they work out what they think and who they want to become. The novel's success across different cultures suggests that readers recognize something in that desire.Â
And Hay Festival offered a real-life version of the same idea. The talks brought us there, but much of what gave the experience purpose happened between them. Perhaps that is what an economy of meaning looks like in practice: not a rejection of speed or efficiency, but recognition that these things don't satisfy every human need.Â
We want the algorithm that finds the book, but we also want the bookshop where we stumble on something we weren’t looking for. And sometimes, instead of an answer, we just want another person to sit with us and our question.Â
AUTHOR
Catalina Tejero is Dean of IE School of Arts & Humanities at IE University and Professor of Practice. Her work is focused on the value of the arts and humanities within the context of current issues, including AI and social change, and how creativity can strengthen human autonomy and provide frameworks for long-term transformation. Catalina is a member of the board of trustees of the Ethosfera Foundation, a Member of Honor of the Foundation Amigos del Museo del Prado in Madrid and a member of the association AWITA – Women in the Arts.