Growth has an extraordinary ability to end an argument. Sales are up, the dashboard turns green, and everyone can discuss bonuses. Asking whether the brand has actually become healthier feels almost impolite. Surely the upward arrow has settled that?
Yet growth can tell different stories. One brand recruits buyers profitably and strengthens its foundations. Another accelerates spectacularly through a single growth driver. A third keeps growing even as its growth drivers approach their limits or its economics deteriorate. A fourth buys today’s results by silently weakening tomorrow’s demand. All four can earn their marketing director’s applause. Only a closer look reveals whether the applause is deserved.
It is useful to distinguish between four types of growth: Healthy, Explosive, Fading, and Toxic. These are practitioner’s categories: useful for managing growth and developing corrective action plans, even if their boundaries are not watertight.
The principle behind them is familiar in finance: the headline number is only the beginning of the analysis. A stock gaining 50% tells you little without examining the risks, volatility, and prospects of sustaining that performance. In marketing, we still too often treat the growth rate as the whole story. The fastest-growing brand gets the conference invitation; the awkward questions can wait.
Assessing the quality of growth requires looking beyond sales to the underlying health of the brand. MADAM provides one way to do so. While the familiar 4Ps – Product, Price, Place, Promotion – describe what marketers manage, MADAM asks whether those choices are strengthening the brand.
- Memorable. A brand needs to come readily to mind in relevant buying situations. When someone thinks, “I need a pick-me-up,” do they think of your energy drink brand? Because growth depends so much on light, lapsed, and new buyers, a brand needs to come to mind at the moment of purchase – even among people who rarely think about it. This is the ‘salience’ emphasized by Jenni Romaniuk and Byron Sharp of University of South Australia, and it is much more demanding than simple brand awareness.
- Available. A brand must be easy to find and buy, in both relevant channels and formats. Shelf visibility, clear merchandising, and packaging suited to the consumer occasion help turn availability into a purchase.
- Desirable. A brand should give people a reason to choose it for that occasion. The stronger that reason, the harder it becomes to substitute another brand without feeling that something has been lost.
- Affordable. A brand needs to fit consumers’ budgets and offer worthwhile value. That does not mean cheap. It means appropriate. A suitable pack size can make a purchase accessible without permanently discounting the product.
- Matches expectations. A brand must walk the talk: deliver the experience that made it desirable in the first place. You might call it quality. Advertising encourages trial; disappointment gives people a reason never to return.
These five dimensions interact constantly. Wider availability increases brand familiarity, supporting memorability. Better quality reinforces desirability and helps justify the price. Disappointment reverses the process: desire weakens, the same price feels less acceptable, and discounting becomes tempting.
Healthy Growth makes the next year easier
Healthy Growth, the first type, progressively strengthens several MADAM dimensions while generating the resources to sustain them.
For example, a successful innovation can connect the brand to a new buying occasion, make it more desirable, and earn greater visibility in stores. Effective communication can strengthen memorability and help consumers understand why the brand is worth paying for. Increased desirability cannot enlarge their budgets, but it can make the price feel more reasonable. These improvements reinforce one another, making growth less dependent on any single driver.
Such progress may take time to appear in sales, market share, and profits. Nevertheless, strengthening these foundations prepares the brand for the medium and long term: the brand is getting fitter and is better equipped to sustain future growth.
Explosive Growth needs a second act
Explosive Growth occurs when exceptional acceleration depends overwhelmingly on one driver. For example, a distribution agreement with a major retailer can transform availability. Viral enthusiasm can make a small new brand extraordinarily desirable within a particular audience. The opportunity is real, but concentrated.
Insurgent brands – young challengers taking on established players – often grow this way, helped by a focused proposition, founder credibility, or an enthusiastic community. But an exceptional year is a poor basis for assuming several more. Research from John Dawes of the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute shows that sustaining market-share growth over several years is much harder than achieving it in one, especially for small brands.
The critical task is to turn that acceleration into Healthy Growth before the initial growth driver reaches its limits. As more people want a brand, they must be able to find it easily, in the formats they need. As it reaches more stores, more shoppers need to know the brand. And to become a regular purchase, it needs a price they are prepared to pay regularly.
Mature brands face a different temptation. Wanting agility and faster growth is legitimate; copying an insurgent’s narrow targeting, influencers, and eccentric positioning may be inappropriate. A challenger finding its first audience has a different job from an established brand serving millions. Borrowing its attitude does not reproduce its starting conditions. An adult wearing a teenager’s clothes is still an adult.
Fading Growth is running out of steam
In this third type of growth, sales are still rising, but the formula sustaining them is losing momentum. The warning may be diminishing returns from a growth driver or deteriorating economics. Where Explosive Growth depends heavily on one engine, Fading Growth means the engine is starting to stall.
Distribution approaches saturation. A competitor recovers from a logistics failure. Flavor extensions deliver diminishing returns, leaving increasingly eccentric candidates for next year’s launch. Enthusiasm for mango does not establish a business case for cucumber.
Most growth drivers have limits. Marketers need to know which ones sustain a brand and develop alternatives before those limits are reached.
Jim Beam in Germany offers an example. For many years, the American whisky brand had grown steadily through distribution gains, flavor extensions, and price promotions. But weighted distribution had reached 96%, and successive flavor extension launches – first honey, then vanilla, then apple – were delivering diminishing returns. As for pricing, almost 80% of volume was already sold on promotion. In other words: all three engines were running short of room.
Meanwhile, growth was shifting toward the premium segment, where Jack Daniel’s was well established and investing heavily. Jim Beam’s weaker premium credentials limited its ability to capture that opportunity. Yet the local team had neither recognized the need to change course nor begun preparing alternatives. The plans conveniently assumed continued growth at the same pace, with the same strategies and the same levers. The slides radiated confidence; a closer look at the growth drivers would have been… sobering.
The profit and loss statement usually offers another warning: growth that generates progressively less value per unit sold. Imagine a brand with volumes rising 8%, net sales 4%, and gross profit just 1%. Revenue per unit and gross margin are falling. The warehouse is busier; the business gets progressively less reward for its effort. This is called deleverage.
Deteriorating mix or fading desirability can produce this pattern: more deals, less profitable or cheaper products sustain volume while margins narrow. Input inflation or margin-dilutive distribution gains can also explain it. The figures call for prompt diagnosis and action, not complacency.
Toxic Growth sends the bill later
Healthy and Explosive Growth can pay. Even Fading Growth can keep paying for a while. Toxic Growth is growth you pay for later. In this fourth type, decisions made to increase sales or protect profit undermine one or more MADAM dimensions, silently weakening the brand’s future earning capacity. Today’s results improve at the expense of the foundations that should sustain tomorrow.
Repeated discounting improves immediate affordability but can erode desirability and pricing power.
An apparently successful extension can consume disproportionate investment, leaving the larger core business underinvested. The launch gets the party; the core gets the hangover.
Wider brand availability can undermine the experience through inappropriate outlets, poor in-store execution, or service standards that cannot keep up.
Product quality can suffer when management pursues profit growth by cutting ingredients or service. With this sort of ‘skimpflation’, the saving reaches the spreadsheet before disappointment reaches the consumer. Once quality deteriorates, desirability weakens, and the price becomes harder to justify.
Cutting advertising expenditure can compound the damage. Less support weakens memorability and demand, while deeper trade discounts subsidize purchases. Margins narrow, inviting further cuts. Brand weakness and financial weakness reinforce each other.
With marketing investment cuts, the scorecard may show a recovery while the business has merely sold the furniture. Cuts can be sustainable when they are accompanied by genuine efficiency gains – such as better scheduling of media campaigns, better-negotiated rates, or a smarter choice of activities that allow the brand to achieve as much or more with less. Otherwise, the saving may simply be an investment shortfall in disguise.
Today’s results are only part of the story. Growth should be judged not only by what it delivers today but by what it leaves behind. Read consumer and financial evidence together, over several years and beneath the averages. Is the flourishing extension concealing a declining core? Are buyers choosing the brand without deeper discounts? What would profit look like with adequate brand support?
Before celebrating a larger business, ask whether it is also better equipped to grow again. Otherwise, next year’s plan may require a deeper discount, a smaller advertising budget, and a flavor nobody asked for.
© IE Insights.








