- Home
- The Pulse
- The Pulse: Articles
- Cleaner Water, Less Waste: Training Microbes To Safeguard Our Drinking Supply
Cleaner water, less waste: Training microbes to safeguard our drinking supply
From the pesticides sprayed on the food we eat to the medicines that leave our bodies as waste, both industry and households are releasing a steady stream of chemical contaminants into the environment. Known as "chemicals of emerging concern," these manmade pollutants are increasingly present in our natural water sources, including rivers and groundwater.Â
These contaminants can have adverse effects on marine life and fragile ecosystems. They also pose risks to public health, both when we swim in these waters and because pollutants enter the food chain, accumulating in what we eat. This includes fish from polluted waters and – as seen with PFAS – even eggs from backyard chickens that have been exposed via the worms they eat. Contaminants also have to be filtered out by treatment plants before water reaches our taps. As the world’s population grows and climate change puts greater pressure on our water sources, the need to safely and sustainably manage chemical pollutants is becoming increasingly urgent.Â
One pioneering solution is being explored by Peer Timmers, Assistant Professor of Environmental Sciences at IE University. His research shows how we can capture naturally occurring microbes and train them to efficiently cleanse our drinking water, minimizing the environmental damage associated with conventional physical-chemical methods.
The cost of chemical water cleaning
The good news is that our drinking water is (nearly) free of these pollutants, thanks to the rigorous and systematic filtration that takes place at water treatment plants. While chemicals of emerging concern have been detected in our drinking water, their levels are extremely low, at a rate equal to a drop of water in an Olympic swimming pool.
Â
The not-so-good news is that removing these chemical pollutants is very costly: not only in monetary terms, but in the immense energy these processes demand and the vast waste they create. UV light filtration, for instance, requires a constant stream of light, consuming between 0.1 and 1 kWh per cubic meter of water to achieve 90% pollutant removal. Ozonization is somewhat more efficient, typically using 0.003–0.3 kWh for the same result, though this can be higher for complex industrial wastewater.
Other methods involve using activated carbon to absorb these unwanted chemicals, but the material must then be burned at 300°C to regenerate, or else sent to landfill. Water can also be pushed through filtration membranes, but the pressure involved demands an immense amount of energy. Additionally, the membranes have a short lifespan and are disposed of in droves, with over 1.5 million modules discarded every year. Each method has an environmental cost, whether in energy consumption or waste production.
Timmers’ research suggests a more sustainable solution to this chemical pollution: training tiny organisms to purify our water supply. And unlike expensive chemical filtration methods, the microbes work for free, requiring only a steady supply of nutrients and the pollutants themselves.Â
How to train a microbe
The method that Timmers is developing involves taking microbes from their natural environment and feeding them the undesired chemicals along with a range of other nutrients that help ensure their survival. Seeing these chemicals as part of their food source, the microbes start producing enzymes that degrade the pollutants by breaking the chemical bonds between certain molecules.Â
This process actually occurs in nature, as seen when microbes that exist in contaminated areas develop an appetite for polluting chemicals, such as toxic heavy metals or methane. For Timmers, these polluted sites make the best hunting grounds. He has been able to take samples of water, soil or sediment containing microbes that have already adapted to pollutants, and train them more easily in the lab.
The next step is to accelerate the speed at which the microbes break down pollutants. This involves a process called enrichment: continuously feeding them the target chemicals while studying which nutrients, substrates and temperatures they respond best to. Once enough of these microbes have grown, they start to overtake any other microbe in the system. Then they can be isolated and applied to specific purposes, such as water treatment.
Finally, the trained microbes can be released into the wild. "We can put them back in our system and ask, do we see an improved rate of degradation? Can they still compete with the local community, with all these other microbes in the system?" explains Timmers.
The 10% sand solution
To gain a deeper understanding of how to optimize microbes for use in water filtration, Timmers’ 2024 experiment explored rapid sand filters at water treatment plants. These filters are used to remove inorganic compounds such as iron and manganese, and have the unintentional effect of removing chemical pollutants to varying degrees. The research involved taking 10% of the sand from an effective sand filter and mixing it, along with all its microbes, into a filter that was drastically underperforming.Â
This practice of introducing beneficial microbes, known as bioaugmentation, ensured the filter had a sufficient supply of the right bacteria. Over the next 80 days, the bacteria were provided with the nutrients they need to survive (a technique known as biostimulation) as well as a cocktail of pollutants.Â
Taking just 10% of the sand from the high-performing filter was a practical choice as well as a scientifically strategic one. Larger amounts would need to be transported by truck, disrupting operations at the treatment plants. However, 80 days of incubating the microbes and feeding them the target chemicals caused a measurable increase in their activity. This means that they can be "farmed."
"If you can grow them that way, you don't need more sand. You could maybe start with just 1% of sand from a successful filter, or even grow the microbes in the lab and add them directly," says Timmers.Â
The results of this experiment confirmed the exciting potential of harnessing biological processes to remove pollution from drinking water. While it didn’t remove all chemicals (the infamous "forever chemical" PFOA was minimally affected), medicines like gabapentin, a nerve pain medication, and metoprolol, a heart drug, were almost completely removed from the treated water, reaching 99% degradation after 38 days.
But the potential of harnessing bacteria for water treatment isn’t limited to pharmaceuticals. In a separate 2020 study of sand filters across the Netherlands and Belgium, Timmers confirmed that biological filtration in existing sand filters is already removing compounds like caffeine, metformin and saccharin, even without optimization.Â
The study also identified two novel transformation products created during biological filtration, meaning that these microbes are already reshaping the chemicals in our water in ways we don’t yet understand.
Why not all chemicals bend to biologyÂ
The sand filter experiment exposed both strengths and shortcomings. The microbes’ inability to conquer PFOA was unsurprising due to the extreme stubbornness of PFAS chemicals. Their carbon-fluorine bond is one of the strongest in organic chemistry, making them incredibly difficult to break down.
Carbamazepine was another chemical that the microbes struggled to break down. This is because it requires a different type of microbes: anaerobic organisms, which don't use oxygen. In this case, Timmers explains, "We probably didn't give the right microbes a chance. If we used other conditions, we would probably see better degradation."
However, breaking down carbamazepine demands significant energy from microbes; energy that would otherwise go toward growth and reproduction. When a compound costs more energy to degrade than it returns, microbes’ growth slows. And in a fast-flowing filter, microbes that aren’t growing quickly enough will be washed away before they can establish themselves.Â
The experiment uncovered a third obstacle: ammonia. It found that the bacteria responsible for cleaning up ammonia were negatively correlated with pollutant removal. "Either ammonia is removed or micropollutants are removed, but not both," explains Timmers.
This was because the microbes that remove ammonia convert it into nitrogen gas using oxygen. The different microbes could therefore be competing for the same oxygen, explains Timmers. A practical solution to avoid this competition might involve implementing two distinct filters at water treatment plants, one targeting ammonia and the other chemical pollutants.Â
Seeing where the chemical-eating microbes succeed and fail is instructive, making it clear that microbial treatment is not a one-size-fits-all process. Careful calibration of the microbes’ conditions and an understanding of the microbial diversity necessary to break down individual chemical pollutants will be pivotal to the success of this approach.Â
A solution, but not a silver bullet
On the positive side, harnessing microbiology for water treatment means avoiding sending large numbers of membranes or activated charcoal to the landfill. This approach also reduces the amount of energy required in the filtration process, as the microbes are able to sustain themselves by feeding on the chemical pollutants. They do require oxygen and will occasionally need reagents to be added to the water, but these are minimal considerations compared to the energy demands of conventional processes.Â
It’s important to clarify, though, that when microbes eat pollutants such as pharmaceuticals, they don’t always disappear completely. "Most of these chemicals are degraded completely to CO2, so they're mineralized and go back into the natural cycle of elements," says Timmers. But in other cases, microbes are only able to break down the chemicals to a certain point, and what’s left over is known as transformation products. Unfortunately, these can sometimes be even more toxic than the initial compound.Â
However, this risk isn’t unique to microbial treatment: it also occurs with oxidation processes such as UV or ozone treatment, as the complex molecules that make up chemical pollutants are broken down into simpler, but more reactive, pieces. Rather than completely replacing these processes with microbes, an intermediary approach could use microbes as a second phase to clean up the toxic compounds produced by oxidation methods.Â
From the lab to the tap
If these pollution-eating microbes can be successfully perfected and isolated, the path to scaling this solution is clear, as they can be grown, sold and shipped directly to water treatment plants. Timmers is quick to highlight the benefits of a combined approach: "I'm not saying microbes are a better technology than physical-chemical methods. I think we need both."
Biological treatment has been used for decades to remove organic matter and ammonia from municipal wastewater and extract heavy metals from industrial wastewater. Now, it has the chance to shine in a new area: the removal of chemicals. "Look at what we have achieved with microbes in the past. These technologies are already being deployed worldwide, and they're profitable," comments Timmers. "If we are able to test this at the pilot scale, we will actually see the true benefits."
By working with nature rather than against it, scientists are opening the door to water treatment methods that are both effective and sustainable.